HBOHBO Forum
glyphstrip  
Halo.bungie.org
glyphstrip
Frequently Asked Forum Questions
 Search the HBO News Archives

Any All Exact 
Search the Halo Updates DBs

BWU Halo Halo2 
Search Older Posts on This Forum:
Posts on Current Forum | Archived Posts

View Thread Reply Return to Index Set Prefs Previous Next
Re: I had no problems with the original.
By:Kermit
Date: 4/30/13 1:31 am
In Response To: Re: I had no problems with the original. (Buttskunk)

: Me too. I like the original ending. Maybe Miller is looking for a job, maybe
: we'll finally get a real Halo game that is...........CANON...

I don't think he needs one. I had the exact criticism months ago, and I actually thought about how easy it would be to remove it, if someone had the equipment.

Different strokes for different folks and all that, but I have to ask people who like the original better, do you have any doubt about what Master Chief is thinking in Cody's version?

To me, not only are the extra lines unnecessary, they're clumsy. Cortana didn't say what Lasky said. They brought up the same idea, but each expressed it differently. Cortana is contrasting herself to Chief. Lasky is stating that soldiers aren't machines. They weren't echoing each other verbatim so the "she said that to me once" line is clumsy because it's not really true, so they tacked on the extra clumsy clarification "... about being a machine." Gag!

It's not uncommon to find weak writing in a game, but placement counts, too. You really don't want to end your game with it.*

Reminds me a bit of the idiomatic "were it so easy," which was misused (twice!) in Halo 3, which would not have been so bad if it weren't a repeating motif that ended the game.*

*post-credit cutscenes notwithstanding


Messages In This Thread

Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Chewbaccawakka4/27/13 10:49 pm
     Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.GrimBrother One4/28/13 12:32 am
     Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Apollo4/28/13 5:27 am
           Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Mixmasterchief4/28/13 9:01 am
     Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Leviathan4/28/13 1:14 pm
           …and she'll feel "fine." *NM*Ragashingo4/28/13 5:46 pm
           Took the words right out of my fingers *NM*Grizzlei4/28/13 6:01 pm
           Holy shit Levi, your post rocksAvateur4/28/13 10:07 pm
           Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Kermit4/28/13 10:31 pm
                 Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.ZackDark4/28/13 10:59 pm
                 Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Cody Miller4/29/13 2:07 am
                       I love you, Cody Miller.Kermit4/29/13 11:58 am
                       Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.RC Master4/29/13 6:01 pm
                       Hot damn, Cody.GrimBrother One4/29/13 6:41 pm
                             Re: Hot damn, Cody.Cody Miller4/29/13 7:13 pm
                                   Re: Hot damn, Cody.Kermit4/29/13 7:54 pm
                                         Absolutely.GrimBrother One4/30/13 1:39 am
                                   Re: Hot damn, Cody.Flynn J Taggart4/30/13 5:43 am
                       Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.TTL Demag0gue4/29/13 11:37 pm
                             I was just going to say the same *NM*thebruce04/30/13 9:37 am
                       Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.TheSparbiter5/2/13 11:42 am
                       Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.General Vagueness5/3/13 8:06 pm
                 Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Leviathan4/29/13 2:24 am
                       Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.General Vagueness5/3/13 8:07 pm
                 Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.uberfoop4/29/13 2:29 am
                       Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Leviathan4/29/13 3:52 am
                             Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.uberfoop4/29/13 4:07 am
                                   Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Stephen L. (SoundEffect)4/29/13 6:39 am
                                         Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.uberfoop4/29/13 9:40 am
                                               Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Stephen L. (SoundEffect)4/29/13 10:53 am
                                                     Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Ragashingo4/29/13 12:56 pm
                                                           Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Stephen L. (SoundEffect)4/29/13 2:37 pm
                                               Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Leviathan4/29/13 1:26 pm
                                         Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Chewbaccawakka4/29/13 1:57 pm
                                               Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Ragashingo4/29/13 2:12 pm
                                                     Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Chewbaccawakka4/29/13 4:04 pm
                                                           Well… Idealistically, we did. :p *NM*Ragashingo4/29/13 6:32 pm
                                               Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Stephen L. (SoundEffect)4/29/13 2:41 pm
           Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Cody Miller4/29/13 1:58 am
                 Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.bluerunner4/29/13 10:11 am
                       [rimshot] *NM*Kermit4/29/13 2:54 pm
                       Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.General Vagueness5/3/13 8:14 pm
                 Agree 1000% *NM*Kermit4/29/13 12:01 pm
                 I prefer this version immensely. *NM*Chewbaccawakka4/29/13 1:59 pm
                 I had no problems with the original.bryan newman4/29/13 7:44 pm
                       Re: I had no problems with the original.Buttskunk4/30/13 12:40 am
                             CodyMiller'sEndingIsNotCanon.netbryan newman4/30/13 1:20 am
                             Re: I had no problems with the original.Kermit4/30/13 1:31 am
                                   Re: I had no problems with the original.Miguel Chavez4/30/13 2:07 am
                                         Re: I had no problems with the original.Kermit4/30/13 8:37 am
                                         Re: I had no problems with the original.Cody Miller4/30/13 1:00 pm
                                               Re: I had no problems with the original.Monochron4/30/13 2:58 pm
                       Re: I had no problems with the original.TheSparbiter5/2/13 11:37 am
                       Re: I had no problems with the original.asa5/3/13 3:20 pm
                 Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.uberfoop4/29/13 7:52 pm
                       Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.davidfuchs4/29/13 8:38 pm
                 Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Miguel Chavez4/30/13 2:15 am
                       Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Cody Miller4/30/13 3:10 am
                             Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Cody Miller4/30/13 3:52 am
                                   Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.thebruce04/30/13 9:47 am
                                         Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Kermit4/30/13 10:43 am
                                         Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Cody Miller4/30/13 12:01 pm
                                   Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Miguel Chavez4/30/13 4:14 pm
                                         Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.Cody Miller4/30/13 5:16 pm
                                               Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.kidtsunami5/1/13 4:28 am
                                         Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.General Vagueness5/4/13 1:37 am
                                   Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.TDSpiral4/30/13 8:07 pm
                                   Re: Halo 4 Ending thoughts. Heh, spoilers.General Vagueness5/4/13 1:25 am

Sign up to post.

You will only be able to post to the forum if you first create a user profile.
If, however, you already have a user profile, please follow the "Set Preferences" link on the main index page and enter your user name to log in to post.