HBOHBO Forum
glyphstrip  
Halo.bungie.org
glyphstrip
Frequently Asked Forum Questions
 Search the HBO News Archives

Any All Exact 
Search the Halo Updates DBs

BWU Halo Halo2 
Search Older Posts on This Forum:
Posts on Current Forum | Archived Posts

View Thread Reply Return to Index Set Prefs Previous Next
Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"
By:thebruce0
Date: 11/2/15 11:04 am

: I'm not sure if you just mean for H5, but I commented on the oddness in my
: old article on H4 at least. Other folk commented about it in the
: subsequent forum thread .

Glad you linked to that thread, I was about to look for it.
I discuss in my posts defending why I believe she was never completely naked. Mainly, no lady bits. At most, skin tight body suit, when the game models could show that geometry detail, and by textures before then.

When it came to her depiction in Halo 4, there was definitely a move towards much more pronounced lady parts, but still no bits :P I still favour the in-universe idea that she's working through her desires to be/appear more human, likely in connection with her personal relationship with John, and also that her appearance is more like a shock-value, demanding attention (as Frankie describes).

"She's not really nude … but that's what it makes you think of," O'Connor explained. "So one of the reasons she [chooses to appear without clothes]* is to attract and demand attention. And she does it to put people off so that they're on their guard when talking to her and she has the upper hand in those conversations."

* I don't have my headphones today at work - what did he really say where the article paraphrases in brackets? Because that paraphrase directly contradicts his first statement in the quote

Whether her appearance would have been more raw and bare if the reservedness is really due to censoring, I suppose we'll never know unless somsone explicitly states that she would have nipples and such if the artists were allowed to depict them in the video game.

But I still don't buy "Cortana is naked", especially in Halo 5, again with the collar and skin tight bodysuit. "Impression of nudity" perhaps, but the character isn't naked. The linked article title is leading. "Why is Cortana naked?" - she's not, and Frankie said it.

So there really are two things, based on what we've seen and are told:
* The model isn't truly naked
* Frankie says "She's not really nude"
So is the latter just a clarification about the game model, because censoring, or is that the in-universe truth of her character's choices?
Is Cortana, in her mind, trying to appear/present herself without clothing (not near-nude, but actually nude)? Are the artists being restricted by what they are allowed to show or not? Or is that a non-issue because the character doesn't actually think she is herself completely naked?

Cortana can form holographic hair. She could certainly form the details for typically censored lady bits. She's not naked. Until those make an appearance, I'll never be able to agree that Cortana is naked. :)


Messages In This Thread

Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naked.Funkmon10/30/15 5:50 pm
     Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's nadavidfuchs10/30/15 6:14 pm
           Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naFunkmon10/30/15 6:22 pm
     Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naGrizzlei10/30/15 6:30 pm
     Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naRockslider10/30/15 6:41 pm
           Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naStretchy10/30/15 11:46 pm
                 Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naRockslider10/31/15 3:03 am
                       Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's nacheapLEY10/31/15 10:11 am
                             Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naRockslider10/31/15 11:17 am
                                   Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naFunkmon10/31/15 3:13 pm
                                         Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naRockslider10/31/15 3:44 pm
                                               Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's nafunkmon10/31/15 5:32 pm
                                                     Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's nascarab11/1/15 3:21 am
                                                     Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naRockslider11/1/15 5:27 am
                                                     Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naGeneral Vagueness11/1/15 6:15 pm
                                   Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's nacheapLEY11/1/15 8:21 pm
                                         Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naRockslider11/1/15 9:30 pm
                                               Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's nacheapLEY11/1/15 10:36 pm
                                                     Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naRockslider11/2/15 1:28 pm
                                                           Re: Did anyone notice? Frankie on why Cortana's naStretchy11/2/15 2:41 pm
           Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"thebruce011/2/15 11:04 am
                 Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"Rockslider11/2/15 12:10 pm
                       Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"thebruce011/2/15 5:24 pm
                             Physical body to carry her holgraphic form?Rockslider11/2/15 6:46 pm
                                   Re: Physical body to carry her holgraphic form?MacGyver1011/3/15 1:42 pm
                                         Re: Physical body to carry her holgraphic form?Rockslider11/3/15 2:52 pm
                                   Re: Physical body to carry her holgraphic form?thebruce011/4/15 4:29 pm
                                         Re: Physical body to carry her holgraphic form?Rockslider11/4/15 7:29 pm
                                               Re: Physical body to carry her holgraphic form?thebruce011/4/15 10:36 pm
                                                     Re: Physical body to carry her holgraphic form?davidfuchs11/5/15 12:10 pm
                                                     Re: Physical body to carry her holgraphic form?Rockslider11/5/15 5:00 pm
                 Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"Stretchy11/2/15 2:17 pm
                 Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"General Vagueness11/3/15 10:33 pm
                       Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"munky-05811/4/15 1:54 pm
                       Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"thebruce011/4/15 4:25 pm
                             Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"General Vagueness11/7/15 4:29 pm
                                   Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"Quirel11/7/15 4:55 pm
                                         Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"Stretchy11/7/15 5:19 pm
                                   Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"SEspider11/7/15 6:20 pm
                                         To Clearify ::IMG::SEspider11/7/15 7:01 pm
                                         Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"munky-05811/7/15 9:16 pm
                                               Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"General Vagueness11/8/15 8:54 pm
                                                     ^^THIS^^ *NM*SEspider11/10/15 3:02 am
                                   Re: Frankie said "She's not really nude"thebruce011/10/15 7:37 pm
                                         Re: I'll cede on this: She's nude if...thebruce011/10/15 8:06 pm

Sign up to post.

You will only be able to post to the forum if you first create a user profile.
If, however, you already have a user profile, please follow the "Set Preferences" link on the main index page and enter your user name to log in to post.