HBOHBO Forum
glyphstrip  
Halo.bungie.org
glyphstrip
Frequently Asked Forum Questions
 Search the HBO News Archives

Any All Exact 
Search the Halo Updates DBs

BWU Halo Halo2 
Search Older Posts on This Forum:
Posts on Current Forum | Archived Posts

View Thread Reply Return to Index Set Prefs Previous Next
On the topic of Halo's story...
By:DHalo
Date: 4/28/17 12:29 pm

So it was Alien Day recently, if you didn't know. I went to a nearby Regal and saw the original Alien in RPX (fancy big screen experience). Also, FYI, first time seeing Alien (I know, right?)

I, of course, noticed plenty of things that Halo drew from: the atmospherics, the architecture both human and alien, the music. But it drew attention to the fact that something Halo 4 and 5 have been sorely lacking is the kind of atmospherics that the original Halo borrowed (and built on) from Alien. I think of 343 Guilty Spark and Two Betrayals and Silent Cartographer and the like, and I think of the atmosphere. The quiet calm clashing with the brief but intense battles that would flare up in each area of the level.

Halo 4 had a lot of this, for sure, but a lot of this was overshadowed for me by the dissonance between characterizations of EU characters now appearing, the general dislikability of almost all of the humans who show up, and the lackluster plot. Halo 5 was overly bombastic and didn't really have many quiet downtime moments that made me feel like I could or even wanted to explore. The awe was just, gone.

Might just be me, might not.


Messages In This Thread

Frankie acknowledges Halo 5's bad storytelling...munky-0584/26/17 4:22 pm
     Re: Frankie acknowledges Halo 5's bad storytellingdavidfuchs4/26/17 5:23 pm
           Re: Frankie acknowledges Halo 5's bad storytellingmunky-0584/26/17 6:14 pm
                 Re: Frankie acknowledges Halo 5's bad storytellingdavidfuchs4/26/17 7:43 pm
                       Re: Frankie acknowledges Halo 5's bad storytellingDHalo4/27/17 3:16 pm
                 343 really wanted Halo 5 to be their Halo 2Revenant19884/26/17 8:59 pm
                       Re: 343 really wanted Halo 5 to be their Halo 2DHalo4/28/17 12:18 pm
                             Re: 343 really wanted Halo 5 to be their Halo 2Revenant19884/28/17 7:39 pm
                                   Re: 343 really wanted Halo 5 to be their Halo 2davidfuchs4/28/17 8:12 pm
                       Re: 343 really wanted Halo 5 to be their Halo 2Dragonclaws4/29/17 3:47 am
           Re: Frankie acknowledges Halo 5's bad storytellingCody Miller4/27/17 9:18 pm
                 Re: Frankie acknowledges Halo 5's bad storytellingdavidfuchs4/27/17 9:41 pm
     In which I try to make a clever analogy:Quirel4/27/17 2:12 am
           Re: In which I try to make a clever analogy:MacGyver104/27/17 3:22 pm
                 Re: In which I try to make a clever analogy:Quirel5/8/17 2:32 am
           Re: In which I try to make a clever analogy:davidfuchs4/27/17 3:33 pm
     The Chief with Spartan companions...scarab4/27/17 3:38 am
     On the topic of Halo's story...DHalo4/28/17 12:29 pm
     At least other folks at 343 are aware...munky-0584/28/17 9:38 pm
     They need to sack their writersscarab5/3/17 12:52 pm
           Re: They need to sack their writersMacGyver105/4/17 6:05 pm
                 Spartan allies have to be OP...scarab5/4/17 9:42 pm
                       What if we find ancient human armour...scarab5/4/17 9:53 pm
                             Re: What if we find ancient human armour...Captain Spark5/4/17 10:59 pm
                             Re: What if we find ancient human armour...MacGyver105/5/17 11:38 am
                 Re: They need to sack their writersmunky-0585/7/17 3:34 am
           Write off the writers. Promote the promoters.Quirel5/8/17 1:46 am
                 Keystone cops. In spaaaace!scarab5/8/17 7:52 am
                       Re: Keystone cops. In spaaaace!munky-0585/8/17 11:40 am
                             Re: Keystone cops. In spaaaace!scarab5/9/17 3:26 pm
                       Re: Keystone cops. In spaaaace!Quirel5/9/17 3:40 am

Sign up to post.

You will only be able to post to the forum if you first create a user profile.
If, however, you already have a user profile, please follow the "Set Preferences" link on the main index page and enter your user name to log in to post.