View Thread Reply Return to Index Set Prefs Previous Next
Re: Halo Reach is Canon
By:Def Guru 7777
Date: 3/3/13 5:09 pm
In Response To: Re: Halo Reach is Canon (Quirel)

: This.

: Does not follow from this.

: So, which is it? A huge retcon, or not much of an issue?

Sigh. There's a difference between non-canon and retconning. A good retconning (those can exist), can be implemented well as long as it accounts for inconsistencies that pop up. Reach is a mostly adequate retcon in those regards. The biggest problem it brings around is the fact that the Autumn is in Aszod when in The Fall of Reach it jumped away right away. But there's a gap between the last chapter and the epilogue, when the Autumn jumps, that it could have gone back to Aszod. It's not perfect, no. But it still isn't an irreconcilable canon issue.

So it's both. A sizeable retcon, and not much of an issue once you give it some thought.


Messages In This Thread

Halo Reach is CanonCody Miller3/3/13 1:40 am
     Re: Halo Reach is CanonGrizzlei3/3/13 2:00 am
     NopeSonGoharotto3/3/13 2:02 am
           Re: NopeAvateur3/3/13 10:40 pm
     Re: Halo Reach is CanonGravemind3/3/13 2:16 am
     Mind Blown. *NM*UnrealCh13f3/3/13 3:23 am
           Re: Mind Blown.ZaneZavin3/3/13 10:05 am
     A.I. ... they're everywhere.Flynn J Taggart3/3/13 5:00 am
           Re: A.I. ... they're everywhere.Quirel3/3/13 4:11 pm
                 Re: A.I. ... they're everywhere.Flynn J Taggart3/3/13 6:15 pm
           Re: A.I. ... they're everywhere.General Vagueness3/3/13 6:30 pm
     Re: Halo Reach is CanonDef Guru 77773/3/13 4:23 pm
           Re: Halo Reach is CanonQuirel3/3/13 5:04 pm
                 Re: Halo Reach is CanonDef Guru 77773/3/13 5:09 pm
     Re: Halo Reach is CanonGeneral Vagueness3/3/13 6:28 pm
     Re: Halo Reach is CanonKermit3/3/13 8:13 pm
     Re: Halo Reach is CanonRagashingo3/3/13 10:33 pm
     Re: Halo Reach is CanonGeneral Vagueness3/30/16 6:10 pm
           Re: Halo Reach is CanonGrizzlei3/30/16 6:17 pm
                 Re: Halo Reach is CanonGeneral Vagueness3/30/16 6:54 pm
                       Re: Halo Reach is CanonChrisTheeCrappy3/30/16 8:17 pm

Sign up to post.

You will only be able to post to the forum if you first create a user profile.
If, however, you already have a user profile, please follow the "Set Preferences" link on the main index page and enter your user name to log in to post.