The game is $60. While value is subjective, it looks to me this $60 game is worth well more than it's price tag. I agree Halo 1 Anniversary was a failure due to the lack of online multiplayer, but they also reduced the price to $40, and gave you more beyond the typical Halo 1 title.

Now we're getting Halo 1's multiplayer online, a revamped Halo 2 (Would be $40 by itself, in comparison to H1A), and Halo 3, and Halo 4 ($60 game) on top of that. And, with everything being in tact, bugs and all, where is room for error?

I don't see how a good time is not guaranteed.