HBOHBO Forum
glyphstrip  
Halo.bungie.org
glyphstrip
Frequently Asked Forum Questions
 Search the HBO News Archives

Any All Exact 
Search the Halo Updates DBs

BWU Halo Halo2 
Search Older Posts on This Forum:
Posts on Current Forum | Archived Posts

View Thread Reply Return to Index Set Prefs Previous Next
Thoughts on CSR
By:Avateur
Date: 3/23/13 2:23 pm

http://www.ign.com/articles/2013/03/23/detailing-halo-4s-competitive-skill-rank-coming-in-april

"There is talk about having stats "turn over" and reset back to zero once you max out at 50 similar to a Call of Duty 'prestige-like' stat reset, but 343i didn't give much more detail as to why or what perks may be attached.

343i did say that they will serve overall resets semi-frequently. They believe resetting things from time to time will motivate people to keep playing and will continually give people new goals."

When Bungie did it in H2, even if due to all the cheaters, it was an extremely frustrating moment. People who had earned their ranks legitimately got caught in the crossfire. The game was already cheated and was going to continue to be cheated, so the rank reset was a joke when Bungie decided to do it. I could only imagine the uproar if Bungie had done it in H3. Now, if 343 handles this in a way where just every so often they go about resetting ranks, sure, why not just go and make CSR meaningless in H4? Hit that reset button. Resetting things from time to time might motivate people to keep playing and continually give people new goals, except that when you're resetting ranks and most likely not giving new goals, you're resetting the whole thing that matters in this playlist and making people less likely to play because you just made their goals a waste of time. I know I wouldn't be too happy getting reset all the time.

Now, if it really is handled like in CoD, where you have the option to Prestige/reset, then I can see that working. People love Prestige! But all that really did was give you extra customization slots, and H4 has a billion of those already. I guess it will depend on how 343 goes about handling it.

Also, if you lose games, will you lose your rank? Or is this going to be some carebear version of ranked gameplay where you always keep your highest level and can always improve on it because they want to hold your hand and never make you feel bad about yourself? If it stays static at your top rank, that could still be highly misleading, especially if you're not really anywhere near that rank and it continues to match you up with people of similar rank. TrueSkill has issues and always has, and could potentially make things problematic depending on how closely it's tied to CSR if CSR stays static. I guess we'll see when more is revealed or once it comes out.


Messages In This Thread

Thoughts on CSRAvateur3/23/13 2:23 pm
     Questions about CSRAvateur3/23/13 2:34 pm
           There should be.Azo 'Galvat3/23/13 3:15 pm
           Re: Questions about CSRRC Master3/23/13 4:24 pm
     Well they didn't really say anything...RC Master3/23/13 4:39 pm
           Re: Well they didn't really say anything...Avateur3/23/13 9:34 pm
                 Re: Well they didn't really say anything...RC Master3/24/13 9:03 am
                       Re: Well they didn't really say anything...Avateur3/24/13 8:32 pm
                             Re: Well they didn't really say anything...RC Master3/25/13 12:22 am
                                   Re: Well they didn't really say anything...RC Master3/25/13 12:27 am
                                         Re: Well they didn't really say anything...Avateur3/25/13 1:38 am
                                   Re: Well they didn't really say anything...Avateur3/25/13 1:27 am
                                   Re: Well they didn't really say anything...General Vagueness3/25/13 6:53 pm
                                         Re: Well they didn't really say anything...RC Master3/25/13 8:01 pm
                                               Re: Well they didn't really say anything...General Vagueness3/26/13 12:15 am
                                                     Ditto on Chrome too *NM*ZackDark3/26/13 12:18 am
     Re: Thoughts on CSRCHa0s3/24/13 2:32 am
     Re: Thoughts on CSRGeneral Vagueness3/24/13 3:24 pm
           Re: Thoughts on CSRSonGoharotto3/24/13 4:09 pm

Sign up to post.

You will only be able to post to the forum if you first create a user profile.
If, however, you already have a user profile, please follow the "Set Preferences" link on the main index page and enter your user name to log in to post.