Frequently Asked Forum Questions
 Search the HBO News Archives

Any All Exact 
Search the Halo Updates DBs

BWU Halo Halo2 
Search Older Posts on This Forum:
Posts on Current Forum | Archived Posts

View Thread Reply Return to Index Set Prefs Previous Next
Re: Why? Is it there?
Date: 6/22/13 9:28 am
In Response To: Re: Why? Is it there? (scarab)

: That's what we saw rising from the tomb. Or it was the tomb.

I don't think it's Mendicant Bias. The only connection I see is the desert setting. But from any logical standpoint, why would the Forerunners leave a giant robot lying around for an AI which they wanted to make sure never escaped its tomb/prison?

More likely, it's a War Sphinx controlled by an as-of-yet-unknown entity; going by the theories that it might actually not be immediately hostile, I wouldn't rule out characters like the IsoDidact. Though judging by 343i's convenient good-evil color coding you'd think they would've used blue or white rather than orange/red to indicate that.

Of course, it could also be the original Didact - it's almost painfully obvious that he survived, but the fake ambiguity gives 343i a chance to play the big villain mystery angle as they did with Halo 4. Only it never really worked because everyone knew who it was going to be. Then again, with the rather negative reception of the Didact's character, they might end up retiring him despite what their original plans might've been. However, it's more probable that they'll give the ol' D another chance, especially now that Silentium has clarified some of the more controversial aspects of his Halo 4 incarnation and the fact they probably have far-reaching plans for him as the next big bad.

Going back to Mendicant Bias, I think Silentium gave a pretty strong indication that Mendicant's tomb is none other than Halo 3's Epitaph. It all fits: a sarcophagus like structure in the Ark's desert sand, a hologram that might very well represent an AI, and obviously the name. The only thing not described in Silentium is the huge spire on top of the tomb, but one can imagine that was built afterwards.

Messages In This Thread

Did I miss the discussion about MB in the trailer? *NM*scarab6/20/13 5:40 pm
     Why? Is it there? *NM*ZackDark6/20/13 6:28 pm
           Re: Why? Is it there?scarab6/21/13 6:08 pm
                 Re: Why? Is it there?ZaneZavin6/21/13 6:17 pm
                       I should get Silentium, shouldn't I? *NM*ZackDark6/21/13 9:25 pm
                             Re: I should get Silentium, shouldn't I?Revenant19886/22/13 8:56 am
                                   Re: I should get Silentium, shouldn't I?General Vagueness6/23/13 6:59 pm
                 Re: Why? Is it there?Archilen6/22/13 9:28 am
                       Re: Why? Is it there?NotTheVacuum6/22/13 10:12 am
     no discussion here, but...Louis Wu6/20/13 7:15 pm
           Re: no discussion here, but...scarab6/21/13 6:02 pm
     It is an exciting theory... *NM*thebruce06/21/13 10:00 am

Sign up to post.

You will only be able to post to the forum if you first create a user profile.
If, however, you already have a user profile, please follow the "Set Preferences" link on the main index page and enter your user name to log in to post.