Alright. Loki, I have a crucial question for you.
According to you, no evidince suggestions that anyone other than Bahl'al could create/did create Thrall, correct?
(Simply put "No, that's not true.", if I'm mistaken.)
According to you, the two battles that are mentioned about Tyr, have nothing to do with each other because no evidince supports that.
(Again, if I'm wrong, just say so, and I'll re-read the posts if I have to.)
What is it that makes your logic, and your beliefs, that much clearer?
There is no evidince that I know of... (Treat this as underlined) ---------
...that would suggest that Bahl'al is the only one to have done so, and that he can -not- be the Watcher.
That is what you need to prove to me, since you're set on saying that we cann't prove he -is-, but you must be able to explain to me (and everyone else here who cares) why your belief is the correct one. Is there any evidince that rules out a relationship?
Now, I'm neutral here, for perhaps the first time since I came to the Asylum. Simply put, what evidince do you have that our beliefs can not be true?
Otherwise, we're running around in circles because there is simply not enough information to do anything else.
I do not believe that the Watcher nessacerily is Bahl'al, but I can not see why he is not.
Perhaps this question will help, though I do not know.
If Bahl'al is the sole source of the Thrall supply...why has no one dominated him/killed him and stole his knowledge from his rotting corpse/bribed him/seduced him or whatever it would take to gain the knowledge to raise them.
I'd love to see you get this accepted as a theory, if its going anywhere. If not, my instinctive beliefs lean towards the Bahl'al=the Watcher theory because I do not see enough evidince to contradict it.
If I've repeated myself, I appolgize for redundancy. If I've offended you, it was not intended.
Seraph
"...it is said that when he grew angry The Longwind's wrath would sweep over the land, scouring the Undead from the Twelve Duns to Forrest Heart, for none could stand to hear his voice for long, bellowing as ten thousand thousands horned bulls."
P.S.
I wrote that as a bit of a joke at my lengthy post.
