: Pretty easy. Andir is a Northman (obviously…really, LR;
: the Province??). You totally forgot the North in this
: argument, and it makes the most sense. There is a
: whole civilization up there, along with cities or
: great villages, yet nothing of it appears on the map.
: What about the cities and war colleges in the Ermine
: that the fir'Bolg have? Not everything is charted…it
: must be Avon's Grove? C'mon.
Hooray! Archer has solved the puzzle with absolutely no need for proof or reasoning!
At least put the effort in to back up your claims. Aside from Andir having a pseudo-berserk name, there isn't much to support him being a Northman. He refers to Alric in a reverant way, and Alric is King of the Province, if he were a northman he would probably refer to a Northman leader rather than the Province leader. The general identity of the Northmen is one of rugged bravery, would they refer to themselves as ragged mercenaries?
I think it's safe to assume he's not fir'Bolg, as Andir has to run across a mile of plain to reach the forest, and there aren't any (visible) mile wide clearings in the Ermine.
LR