: I don't. :-) And you'll recall that the original
: Deceiver-lives theories were also created on the
: strength of in-game evidence (postgame pics, narration
: and Soulblighter's failure to escape at the end).
: There are a *huge* number of discrepancies with the
: journals on The Wall, Shiver, Twice Born and The
: Forge. I'm very sure that Twice Born actually occurred
: on Monday--see my long boring post at
:
: http://carnage.bungie.org/myth/asylum/asylum.forum.pl?read=10060
: (which you said you agreed with once--although of course
: you're free to change your mind. :-)
: Anyway, if that's correct then the statement implying the
: Deceiver's survival occurs two days after his apparent
: "death." And if the crow's death was all
: that was needed to stop Soulblighter, then it would
: have been irrelevant whether The Deceiver held onto it
: or not. It was already Kentucky-fried at the end of
: "A Murder of Crows."
: Well, first of all, there's no such thing as "as
: good as dead" when applied to a Fallen Lord.
: "Yes, he's a super-powerful sorcerer, but hey, I
: saw him fall into a river and lose his scepter, so
: let's forget about him?" Giving up on finding
: Damas is understandable--no one knows what happened to
: him and he could be anywhere--but if they actually
: knew where Myrdred's comatose body lay, it'd only make
: sense for Alric to hike up there on a weekend and tear
: his head off.
: Second, Alric didn't seem to even know the basics of what
: had happened to The Deceiver. He just "believed
: that the Deceiver still lived," and had yet to
: get the details from Twelve Motion. Only after
: "Through The Ermine" did Twelve Motion
: finally come out with his story of the Deceiver's
: undoing. That seems a bit irresponsible to me...
: Says the man who introduced the concept of
: "contemporaneous reincarnations of the same
: spirit" into the Asylum. :-)
: --SiliconDream
OK,i think he is dead because in the myth2 epilogue narration the narrator clearly stated that the fallen lords are dead and that does include myrdred atleast i think so.