HBOHBO Forum
glyphstrip  
Halo.bungie.org
glyphstrip
Frequently Asked Forum Questions
 Search the HBO News Archives

Any All Exact 
Search the Halo Updates DBs

BWU Halo Halo2 
Search Older Posts on This Forum:
Posts on Current Forum | Archived Posts

View Thread Reply Return to Index Set Prefs Previous Next
Re: Humanity: all one happy family?!?
By:Postmortem
Date: 12/24/21 7:15 pm
In Response To: Re: Humanity: all one happy family?!? (davidfuchs)

: 343 has focused on that aspect far more—from the opening cutscene of Halo 4,
: to dredging up that past in Infinite's haunting... visions? Not quite
: flashbacks? Not sure what you'd call them.

Memory fragments?

: eBut I think, especially with a T-rated game, there's a hard limit to how far
: they can go with it, not to mention I think there's an overriding gameplay
: reason they're not interested in having us fight humans, because it's
: going to be relatively boring compared to interesting aliens with
: interesting alien weapons. The choice they've made with the character also
: limits that kind of story in that Chief is ultimately a-okay with being a
: child soldier because it's all he's known, and he'd probably be dead
: otherwise. You'd really need another character to cover that, and I'm not
: sure you'd ever be able to get more than glancing blows at the problem in
: a game medium where you have to make shooting other living things fun.

Chief really was the standout in terms of accepting his destiny as a Spartan right out the gate. Because FoR was told from his perspective, the impact on the rest of the kids wasn't seen until later. Chief really was the oddity among a lot of other children that were traumatized, brutalized, scared, and just wanting to go home... until the indoctrination did its work. But even then, you've got the kids who waited until after their augmentations to escape, all the suicides, etc.

I agree the games won't ever go into it in more than a cursory way, because it's more fun to embody a super soldier without moral ambiguity. But I still hope 343 doesn't abandon that thread of John reclaiming his humanity. I feel Infinite did a good job of including just enough of his emotional progress to continue that narrative.


Messages In This Thread

Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoilersPostmortem12/19/21 9:07 pm
     Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiJoe Duplessie (SNIPE 316)12/18/21 4:37 pm
           Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiPostmortem12/20/21 12:33 am
                 Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiQuirel12/20/21 10:12 am
                       Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiDHalo12/22/21 1:37 am
                             Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiPostmortem12/22/21 1:00 am
                                   Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiDHalo12/21/21 11:11 am
                                         Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiPostmortem12/21/21 11:11 am
                                   Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiQuirel12/24/21 7:17 pm
                                         Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiDHalo12/22/21 9:51 am
                                         Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiPostmortem12/25/21 2:36 am
                                               Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiDHalo12/26/21 11:50 pm
                                                     Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiPostmortem12/25/21 7:57 pm
                                                           100% AgreedDHalo12/25/21 7:57 pm
                                                     Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiUrsusArctos12/26/21 11:50 pm
                             Humanity: all one happy family?!?scarab12/26/21 11:42 pm
                                   Re: Humanity: all one happy family?!?davidfuchs12/24/21 7:15 pm
                                         Re: Humanity: all one happy family?!?Postmortem12/24/21 7:15 pm
                                   Re: Humanity: all one happy family?!?DHalo12/21/21 4:36 pm
                                   Re: Humanity: all one happy family?!?Quirel12/22/21 1:54 am
                                   Re: Humanity: all one happy family?!?UrsusArctos12/26/21 11:42 pm
                             Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiQuirel12/22/21 1:37 am
     Maybe, maybe not.DHalo12/18/21 6:14 pm
           That said...DHalo12/18/21 6:14 pm
     Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiQuirel12/18/21 10:09 pm
     Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoidavidfuchs12/21/21 12:29 am
           Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoiPostmortem12/21/21 8:39 am
                 Re: Can we talk about that Legendary Ending? *spoidavidfuchs12/21/21 8:39 am

Sign up to post.

You will only be able to post to the forum if you first create a user profile.
If, however, you already have a user profile, please follow the "Set Preferences" link on the main index page and enter your user name to log in to post.