HBOHBO Forum
glyphstrip  
Halo.bungie.org
glyphstrip
Frequently Asked Forum Questions
 Search the HBO News Archives

Any All Exact 
Search the Halo Updates DBs

BWU Halo Halo2 
Search Older Posts on This Forum:
Posts on Current Forum | Archived Posts

View Thread Reply Return to Index Set Prefs Previous Next
Distinguishing between relevant & irrelevant
By:The Lionheart
Date: 2/19/16 4:03 pm

: Not to be disrespectful, but whenever I see thread like this and people
: expressing such anger of minutiae, it reminds me of the nerds from Galaxy
: Quest. That's supposed to be a parody! Nobody is supposed to be like that
: in real life!

Hey, Cody! Thanks for making your intentions clear that you are not trying to be disrespectful. I certainly appreciate that and intend to return the favor. :)

You asserted that Commander Shepard and those who relate to the expression of his feelings of anger and frustration over the Halo 5 Mark V Alpha asset are "angry over minutiae."

So, as it turns out, the premise of that assertion is flawed.

An individual's definition of "minutiae" within that specific context that you are referencing, is subjective. To many people over 65, for example, the entirety of videogames, and absolutely everything that has to do with the lot of them (For example, whether or not Halo Reach's campaign adheres to the previously established canon) would fall under those folks' definition of minutiae.

Different strokes for different folks.

To you, it may be legitimately minute. But to many of us, it is not.

(For clarity's sake, here is the Google'd definition of minutiae:)

miˇnuˇtiˇae
noun
plural noun: minutia

the small, precise, or trivial details of something.

"the minutiae of everyday life"

synonyms: details, niceties, finer points, particulars, trivia, trivialities

"the captain cannot be concerned with the minutiae of shipboard life"



The difference in design between the asset that this was supposed to be, and the asset that it ended up being, is not minute.

It is actually quite large (as demonstrated). But of course, this post and its replies were not created in response to mere technical details being incorrect. It is what those "technical details being incorrect" signify that caused this.

To many of us, they signify consequential apathy (towards us and towards what we love: namely, Halo itself).

They signify the fact that certain people in authority who should have cared more, didn't. (And they signify the consequential implications of that fact thereby).

They signify the latest entry into a pattern of events that paint a picture we dislike enough to respond to.

At the end of the day, what events like these signify is a failure in stewardship -- and for those of us who care, such events demand being responded to in (hopefully) productive ways.

It would be all too easy to simply generalize all fan-borne criticisms such as these into a giant blob, where lines are blurred and distinctions are lost (and where you can justify anything and everything that you do because everything is relative and there is no objective truth to the matter, so just do what feels good at the time, and whoever objects to that can just go suck an egg or something, because who cares?), but I would encourage everyone who feels that way to reconsider that, when you take away the subjectivity of how individuals classify what they consider to be minutiae, it all really just comes down to one straightforward concept: If you're going to do it at all, then you should do it right.

Period.


Messages In This Thread

An open rebuke of H5's "Mark V Alpha" *IMGs*The Lionheart2/18/16 10:10 pm
     Re: An open rebuke of H5's "Mark V Alpha" *IMGs*Tuckerscreator2/18/16 10:19 pm
     Re: An open rebuke of H5's "Mark V Alpha" *IMGs*Revenant19882/18/16 10:27 pm
           I really wish I could 3D model :( *NM*Revenant19882/18/16 10:29 pm
     TC is the guy who should be getting 343i's money.munky-0582/18/16 10:31 pm
           Re: TC is the guy who should be getting 343i's monArchilen2/19/16 12:21 am
           Re: TC is the guy who should be getting 343i's monCody Miller2/19/16 1:19 pm
                 We're not all angryscarab2/19/16 1:45 pm
                 Can't help but be upset...bryan newman2/19/16 2:06 pm
                 haloreach.isnotcanon.net *NM*Grizzlei2/19/16 2:06 pm
                       Oh yes! I forgot about that. *NM*scarab2/19/16 2:08 pm
                       Re: haloreach.isnotcanon.netCody Miller2/19/16 3:39 pm
                             Re: haloreach.isnotcanon.netQuirel2/19/16 5:36 pm
                 Re: NitpickingTuckerscreator2/19/16 3:35 pm
                       Re: NitpickingMacGyver102/19/16 4:38 pm
                 Distinguishing between relevant & irrelevantThe Lionheart2/19/16 4:03 pm
                       Re: Distinguishing between relevant & irrelevantCody Miller2/19/16 4:44 pm
                             Re: Distinguishing between relevant & irrelevantTekkaCroe2/19/16 5:19 pm
                             Not *the* problem.Nikko B2012/19/16 5:23 pm
                                   Re: Not *the* problem.Cody Miller2/19/16 5:39 pm
                                         Re: Not *the* problem.gamerguy20022/20/16 9:21 pm
           Re: TC is the guy who should be getting 343i's monasa2/19/16 2:48 pm
     Still the best comparison we have *IMG*Grizzlei2/18/16 11:03 pm
     TekkaCroe has mad skillsscarab2/19/16 10:00 am
     Re: An open rebuke of H5's "Mark V Alpha" *IMGs*Bryan newman2/29/16 10:59 pm
     Now THAT's more like it. :)The Lionheart12/6/16 7:56 pm
           Re: Now THAT's more like it. :)macgyver1012/7/16 12:26 pm
                 Re: Now THAT's more like it. :)Grizzlei12/7/16 12:41 pm
                       Re: Now THAT's more like it. :)davidfuchs12/7/16 1:53 pm
                             Re: Now THAT's more like it. :)Nikko B20112/7/16 9:13 pm
                                   Re: Now THAT's more like it. :)macgyver1012/8/16 11:35 am
                                         Re: Now THAT's more like it. :)Nikko B20112/8/16 10:34 pm
                                               Awesome, thanks! *NM*macgyver1012/9/16 10:35 am
           Re: Now THAT's more like it. :)asa12/7/16 1:08 pm
           MkV in actiondavidfuchs12/10/16 12:52 pm

Sign up to post.

You will only be able to post to the forum if you first create a user profile.
If, however, you already have a user profile, please follow the "Set Preferences" link on the main index page and enter your user name to log in to post.