HBOHBO Forum
glyphstrip  
Halo.bungie.org
glyphstrip
Frequently Asked Forum Questions
 Search the HBO News Archives

Any All Exact 
Search the Halo Updates DBs

BWU Halo Halo2 
Search Older Posts on This Forum:
Posts on Current Forum | Archived Posts

View Thread Reply Return to Index Set Prefs Previous Next
Re: Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*
By:Quirel
Date: 6/22/15 6:49 pm

: I don't know why they would
: deflect bullets, rather than vaporise them as they pass through the
: plasma, but I also assumed that the sword would deflect plasma bolts for
: similar reasons.

Yeah, I doubt the sword will deflect plasma bolts. The bolts from a Plasma Pistol or Plasma Rifle aren't ballistic, but projected by a magnetic containment field generated by the weapon. A plasma rifle isn't going to 'reflect' that containment field.

: I've also seen people who thought it was made of
: hardlight instead of plasma, though. I suppose it's the same argument
: behind "why do lightsabers not pass through each other" - I
: could rattle off a bunch of scientific ideas or fanon assumptions, but in
: the end it's just because it's cooler that way.

Why do lightsabers reflect blaster shots? Why do they cut through anything but another lightsaber? They just do. That's all there is to it. George Lucas wanted kickass swordfights in Star Wars like the ones in the serials he saw as a kid, and the best way to do that is to make lightsabers operate on the same principles as theatrical swordfighting.

It's not the only way to choreograph a swordfight, especially in print. Well, is it alright if I bring up K. J. Parker again? Because I'm going to bring her up. She's written swordfights before, and she's enough of a Renaissance fan that she knows what she's talking about. Her characters don't just swing and parry and search for weak spots, they talk themselves through strategy, footwork, and timing. There was one character that got into a fight and realized from the get-go that there was no way he was going to win this fight, because the other guy was using a sort of footwork that gave him better avenues of attack.

And then Parker applied these rules of swordfighting to diplomacy and war. It was awesome.

So, what if energy blades can't parry? What if they pass straight through each other, perhaps momentarily disrupting each other? That would make sword duels short and brutal for the survivor. A Sangheili is either a scarily competent swordfighter, or they don't survive more than one duel. Fights are all about feints, evasions and displacement.

It would take a writer who really knows swordfights to make this work, but then again Halo's never had a good swordfight scene. Time for that to change.


Messages In This Thread

Hunters in the DarkBigO6/17/15 11:22 pm
     Re: Hunters in the DarkQuirel6/17/15 11:27 pm
           Re: Hunters in the Dark *minor SP*BigO6/17/15 11:43 pm
                 Re: Hunters in the Dark *minor SP*Apollo6/17/15 11:56 pm
                 Re: Hunters in the Dark *SP*asa6/18/15 9:13 pm
                       Re: Hunters in the Dark *SP*7he grunt w/a plasma pistol6/18/15 10:15 pm
                       Re: Hunters in the Dark *SP*Grizzlei6/18/15 10:24 pm
     The story so far... *SP*Grizzlei6/17/15 11:56 pm
           Re: The story so far... *SP*Apollo6/17/15 11:58 pm
                 Re: The story so far... *SP*Grizzlei6/18/15 12:00 am
           Re: The story so far... *SP*BigO6/18/15 12:13 am
                 Re: The story so far... *SP*Grizzlei6/18/15 12:24 am
                       Re: The story so far... *SP*Quirel6/18/15 1:19 am
                 Re: The story so far... *SP*Apollo6/18/15 12:32 am
                       Re: The story so far... *SP*GrimBrother One6/18/15 12:34 am
                             Re: The story so far... *SP*Grizzlei6/18/15 2:59 am
           I'm really surprised *SP*Grizzlei6/18/15 10:35 pm
     Re: Hunters in the Dark *possibly free*asa6/18/15 9:21 pm
     So were N'tho and co. in the Ark control room?davidfuchs6/19/15 12:11 pm
     Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*Quirel6/20/15 7:36 pm
           Re: Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*Morhek6/20/15 9:41 pm
                 Re: Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*Apollo6/21/15 2:10 am
                 Re: Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*Quirel6/22/15 6:49 pm
                       Superstardestroyer VS Enterprise Escarab6/23/15 5:25 am
                             As a Trekkie, I say the correct answer is:Gravemind6/23/15 8:26 pm
                             Re: Superstardestroyer VS Enterprise EQuirel6/24/15 1:21 am
                             More thoughts (I'm turning into Vagueness)Quirel6/25/15 4:43 am
                                   Re: More thoughts (I'm turning into Vagueness)cheapLEY6/25/15 8:28 pm
                                         Re: More thoughts (I'm turning into Vagueness)Quirel6/26/15 2:25 am
                                   I'm turning Vagueness i generally think so *NM*Bounce-A-Gon6/25/15 10:17 pm
                 Re: Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*General Vagueness6/26/15 6:13 pm
           Re: Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*Azo 'Galvat6/21/15 12:19 am
           Re: Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*Vincent6/21/15 3:55 am
                 Re: Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*Quirel6/22/15 1:26 pm
                       IIRC...Metalingus6276/22/15 2:21 pm
                             Re: IIRC...Quirel6/22/15 2:48 pm
                             I never betrayed themscarab6/22/15 6:28 pm
                                   Re: I never betrayed themMetalingus6276/23/15 6:26 am
                                         But Buck said that Brutes ARE more fun to fight *NM*scarab6/25/15 8:26 am
           Re: Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*Stephen L. (SoundEffect)6/21/15 1:29 pm
                 Re: Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*Quirel6/22/15 1:04 pm
           Re: Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*Quirel6/22/15 4:37 am
                 Re: Reading Hunters in the Dark, and... *SP*Archilen6/22/15 5:29 am
     Two questionsKermit6/22/15 3:48 pm
           Re: Two questionsGrizzlei6/22/15 3:53 pm
           Re: Two questionsQuirel6/22/15 6:36 pm
     On a completely different note...Arithmomaniac6/26/15 6:29 pm

Sign up to post.

You will only be able to post to the forum if you first create a user profile.
If, however, you already have a user profile, please follow the "Set Preferences" link on the main index page and enter your user name to log in to post.